MAGA Supporters for Mamdani and a New Progressive Alliance: Key Unexpected Outcomes from New York’s Mayoral Race

Just two days before the NYC mayoral election, Michael Lange issued a significant forecast – not just the winner citywide, but block by block. Lange, a political analyst born and raised in the city, has spent more than ten years in progressive politics and has become a kind of local celebrity this year for his deep dives into municipal statistics and polling.

He released his highly detailed prediction map – which correctly forecast that the progressive candidate was victorious while failed to predict Andrew Cuomo’s strong performance – on his newsletter, his platform. He has a flair for witty coinages. He pointed out, as an example, the split between the “commie corridor”, stretching from Park Slope to Bushwick to a third locale, where he predicted (correctly) that the left-wing candidate would triumph by large leads, and the “capitalist corridor” on affluent parts of Manhattan. There, “the Free Press and Wall Street Journal surpass the mainstream paper” in readership and the majority of electors leaned toward Cuomo, who ran as a conservative-courting independent.

Election Night Patterns and Unexpected Results

What was your election night?

It was necessary since they were dropping approximately 200K ballots into the tally frequently! I felt a little nervous initially: The candidate was ahead the early vote by 12 points, but there were large groups of votes added later and the advantage went from 12 to 8%. It was concerning.

You know, it was possible in which yesterday went kind of poorly for Mamdani, where Cuomo was going to end up basically doubling his votes from the earlier contest. However the winner added 500,000 supporters to his initial base, and this was critical why he won. He went out and massively expanded his base from the first round.

Coalition Building

How did the mayor-elect gain additional support from?

He built the alliance that progressives always wanted to build: diverse racially, youthful, tenants and it’s people squeezed by affordability. He gained significantly with Black and Hispanic voters, working- and middle-class voters, compared to the earlier election. Additionally he boosted his base of left-leaning activists, youthful radicals, and Muslims and south Asians. Victory required without expanding his appeal.

He built the coalition that the left long aimed for: diverse, youthful, renters and residents struggling with costs

There were also a number of Trump/Mamdani voters – is this significant?

It is a genuine phenomenon, limited to Hispanic laborers, Asian communities and Muslims. Electors in immigrant strongholds that supported Trump last year backed Zohran now. However it’s not that he was winning over white working-class voters and Maga voters.

Turnout and Impact

One of the big stories of the election was the sky-high turnout. Who benefited?

Both sides. Turnout was much greater than I had expected. I thought it could exceed 2 million, but it’s closer to 2.3M – which is a lot of darn voters. There was a substantial anti-Mamdani block, who were motivated, but his supporters was also motivated, and that was enough to secure victory.

You predicted he’d exceed 50% of the vote. Is he likely for that?

Currently it appears he’s likely to surpass 50%. He’s at just over 50% but there’s still probably 200,000 votes uncounted as of Wednesday morning. Thus I don’t think certain, but I think it’s likely, and I hope he does because then no one can say the Republican was a spoiler.

Republican Collapse

Curtis Sliwa, the Republican candidate, is the other big story. His support completely collapsed.

He didn’t win any district in any area. Not even Tottenville in Staten Island, which is like an highly conservative area. That really surprised me. Cuomo kept very white areas, affluent zones and devout communities, and then added many Republicans on Staten Island who had a strong turnout. I believe there was significant strategic balloting by GOP voters. This happened prior to the former president tweeted his support for Cuomo, but it assisted. It might have changed the outcome unless Mamdani’s coalition failed to expand.

Progressive Strongholds

What about your often-discussed left-wing base – was support for Mamdani dominant in those areas of the boroughs?

In my view existed a little dilution of the commie corridor in certain places like neighborhoods that have more older white ethnic folks. In Astoria, instance, the property owners and residents supported Cuomo. Thus there existed some opposition. But overall, largely the leftist base is another huge reason why Mamdani prevailed – he was polling between 77% and 83% in specific neighborhoods.

Community Support

Prior to the vote there was coverage on if Mamdani was gaining ground with the community. Any indication that he did?

There are areas with many non-religious and left-inclined voters – like Park Slope and Morningside Heights – where he did well. However in the wealthy Jewish communities such as the Manhattan area, his Middle East stance definitely mattered there. Likewise in the more middle-class Jewish areas including Forest Hills, Rego Park, or Bronx areas – they all leaned Cuomo. Plus, there are newcomers from the former Soviet Union in southern Brooklyn, who were pretty staunchly supportive. Therefore it’s unclear if there were major surprises here, but he did hold more progressive Jewish neighborhoods and including sections of the another locale by big margins.

Long-Term Significance

Has Mamdani rewritten what New York means politically? Will progressive base serve as a springboard for leftwing candidates?

Yes, it’s not accidental that key political leaders from the left hail from a handful of neighborhoods in the boroughs. I believe that we’ll see more of that – candidates will emerge from these neighborhoods to be promoted to higher office.

However I believe that every city in America could develop similar progressive hubs. Cities are the centers of leftwing power in the nation – since youth reside there, people rent and they are places where people are crushed by the disparities exist.

Jasmin Curtis
Jasmin Curtis

A software engineer and tech writer passionate about open-source projects and digital transformation, with over a decade of industry experience.